JLM Review Form – Experiment
Relevance to JLM (how well does the article adhere to the scope of the journal?)*
Originality (are new ideas presented, or is this just yet another paper on…?)*
Impact (is the paper likely to have a lasting impact on the field?)*
Evaluation (is the proposal appropriately evaluated?)*
Meaningful comparison (are there substantial references to relevant prior work?)*
Presentation (organisation, clarity)*
Language quality (is the article written in good English?)*
Review*
Remarks for the Editor
* Denotes required field